Season One

Writers
Episode Title
Rating
1 1-1 Eric Kripke Pilot 7
2 1-2 Eric Kripke Wendigo  
3 1-3 Raelle Tucker, Sera Gamble Dead in the Water + 10
4 1-4 Richard Hatem Phantom Traveler + 10
5 1-5 Terri Hughes Burton, Ron Milbauer Bloody Mary  
6 1-6 John Shiban Skin  
7 1-7 John Shiban Hookman  
8 1-8 Rachel Nave, Bill Coakley Bugs  
9 1-9 Eric Kripke Home  
10 1-10 Richard Hatem Asylum  
11 1-11 John Shiban Scarecrow  
12 1-12 Raelle Tucker, Sera Gamble Faith + 10
13 1-13 Eugenie Ross-Leming, Brad Buckner Route 666  
14 1-14 Sera Gamble, Raelle Tucker Nightmare  
15 1-15 John Shiban The Benders  
16 1-16 Eric Kripke Shadow  
17 1-17 Trey Callaway Hell House  
18 1-18 Daniel Knauf Something Wicked +  
19 1-19 David Ehrman Provenance  
20 1-20 Cathryn Humphris, John Shiban Dead Man's Blood  
21 1-21 Raelle Tucker, Sera Gamble Salvation  
22 1-22 Eric Kripke Devil's Trap +  

Season Two

    Writers Episode Title Rating
23 2-1 Eric Kripke In My Time of Dying + 10
24 2-2 John Shiban Everybody Loves a Clown  
25 2-3 Sera Gamble Bloodlust + 10
26 2-4 Raelle Tucker Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things  
27 2-5 Ben Edlund Simon Said 9
28 2-6 Matt Witten No Exit 7
29 2-7 Cathryn Humphris The Usual Suspects 9
30 2-8 Sera Gamble Crossroad Blues 9
31 2-9 John Shiban Croatoan + 10
32 2-10 Raelle Tucker Hunted + 10
33 2-11 Matt Witten Playthings 8
34 2-12 Ben Edlund Nightshifter 9.5
35 2-13 Sera Gamble Houses of the Holy + 8
36 2-14 Cathryn Humphris Born Under A Bad Sign + 10
37 2-15 John Shiban Tall Tales 6
38 2-16 Raelle Tucker Roadkill 1
39 2-17 Sera Gamble Heart 2
40 2-18 Ben Edlund Hollywood Babylon 7
41 2-19 John Shiban Folsom Prison Blues 8
42 2-20 Raelle Tucker What Is And What Should Never Be + 10
43 2-21 Sera Gamble All Hell Breaks Loose, Pt. 1 7.5
44 2-22 Eric Kripke All Hell Breaks Loose, Pt. 2 + 10

Season Three

    Writers Episode Title Rating
45
3-1
 Eric Kripke The Magnificent Seven 6
46
3-2
 Sera Gamble The Kids Are Alright  
47
3-3
 Ben Edlund Bad Day at Black Rock 9.5
48
3-4
 Robert Singer, Jeremy Carver Sin City 9.5
49
3-5
 Cathryn Humphris Bedtime Stories  
50
3-6
 Laurence Andries Red Sky At Morning + 10
51
3-7
 Sera Gamble Fresh Blood 6.5
52
3-8
   A Very Supernatural Christmas  
53
3-9
      
54
3-10
      
55
3-11
      
56
3-12
      
57
3-13
      
58
3-14
      
59
3-15
      
60
3-16
      
61
3-17
      
62
3-18
      
63
3-19
      
64
3-20
      
65
3-21
      
66
3-22
      

 

© Voice of Reason, 2007